Tuesday, July 21, 2009

To be or not to be - single…that is the question


I insert the key to my front door while trying to balance my laptop with a jhola full of vegetables. My neighbour’s four year old son zooms past on his tricycle, “You are lucky,” his mother says enviously, “no worries, no children, no husband. I can’t work because of - Roshen! leave Goodlu alone!! (that’s to her hyperactive son!)…I’m bored.”


She’s not like the other lady who lives opposite my flat – married, with a year old child left to the care of an aaya while she’s at the office all day and the husband is working in the gulf.

Three women. Different choices. Mine is a little uncommon in the Indian scenario - a woman deciding to stay single. Someone who could have married well, led a safe, socially acceptable, economically stable life. But didn’t. At my age, it’s not a case of delay, arriving late at the station – it’s giving the marital bandwagon a bypass. It’s a statement.

For my neighbour who’s chosen to be a housewife, I’m an object of envy. For a friend who’s going through a rocky marriage, I’m a source of strength. For a colleague who doesn’t find me depressed or seeking attention even when I was sick (and alone in a new city), I’m an enigma. To my parents I’m a heartache. For a lot of men I’m an object of curiosity – and more…

The reasons why being single is regarded as strange and unusual has to do with the business of being human. While modernization, affordable cell phones, ATMs, dial-a-whatever-you-want, has led to an opportunity for the individual (even women!) to live more as an individual than a social stereotype, there are yet formidable questions that crave for answers. Of them, are the practical issues like what happens when you are sick or have an accident. But more important are the age old questions of emotional bonding, of love, of loneliness…

People, often ask me why I’ve not married. The answer is really simple though not always understood. I haven’t married because I’m happier staying single. I actually ENJOY solitude, it’s not a burden or a self imposed discipline. I can spend days together in my flat listening to music, doing yoga, reading, writing, playing flute or just sitting watching the clouds, the noisy traffic, the labourers constructing another tall building…I don’t need to have a man designated to me as ‘husband’ with a set of rights and duties towards me to feel complete or safe. Besides, I’m addicted to the freedom of not having to answer or explain to someone. Even though I don’t party or plunge in any wild pleasures, I like the idea of not having to live up to a role or mould myself to someone else’s expectations. Selfish? Perhaps.

A friend sizzling with sceptism is quick to retort, “What happens when you open the door to an empty house - tired, worn out, worried and there’s nobody to give you a cup of tea or listen to you…don’t you wish you were married?” I do come back tired sometimes and since I’m working far away from my home town and my parents, I have to make that coveted cup of tea myself, but this or similar needs have never made me turn to marriage as an answer.

It would of course, be naïve to assume that every single person will commit an entire life to isolation and celibacy. One may have intimate friends and family to share matters of the heart with, even at long distance. Besides, romantic relationships do happen sometimes, but they don’t always culminate in marriage. However, to assume as some people do (especially landlords!) that a single’s life is characterized with indiscipline, wild parties, one night stands or casual sex is ridiculous and irrational.

I respect marriage as an institution (for others!) and regard G.B Shaw’s view of calling it “legalized prostitution” as extreme. Marriage makes it obligatory for your spouse to take care of you in times of need, which may be a major problem if you are single and staying alone without friends or relatives nearby. A traditional marriage is perhaps the best system for bringing up physically and emotionally healthy children, however, it doesn’t always guarantee an intimate bond with one’s spouse, emotional understanding, inner growth or even sexual satisfaction. If one is emotionally and financially independent, a single life is a privilege and luxury. The freedom to choose one’s actions and life style, the privilege of organizing one’s own time, the joy of physical and mental space, come easy if you are single. But if one is not emotionally strong and needs to have company or a legally secured partner then it’s better to climb onto the marital bandwagon than to venture the road less traveled. Everything comes at a price. People pay for being married, I pay for being single and with a hand on my heart I can say it’s well worth it. Being single, one is singularly happy.

- Harvinder Kaur

4 comments:

  1. Swati22.7.09

    While I agree completely with your views on the reasons for choosing to remain single and all the unnecessary stigma and issues that society attaches with it, I think the view presented on why people get married is somewhat lopsided since 1) instances of the 2 women are not exactly those of happily married ones even though there are plenty belonging to all kinds of marriages. 2) People don't get married only because they are not emotionally strong or want a legally and financially secured partner who will bring them a cup of tea when they are tired, even though there are plenty again who do marry for the same reasons.

    Many, such as myself and the close friends I have, do get married simply because they find the person they truly completely bond with at a very deep level such that choosing to spend their lives together is only a natural outcome of their relationship and bond. The marriage then becomes simply a legal certificate that keeps pesky parents, relatives and the society 'satisfied' and consequently and more importantly at bay! Also, couples like us often spend a lot of 'alone' time happily by ourselves, each person having many activities we pursue without the other's involvement and my husband does not bring me a cup of tea when I am tired - I prefer I make one myself not least because he doesn't quite know how to !

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Swati!

    Sorry if I sounded like a misogamist! I think your comment is heartening, and also pretty much a breath of rose tinged air - much craved for by many!

    Of course, there are happy marriages! I guess happy people don't always talk about the space they live in as much the unhappy ones do! Anyway, the purpose of my article was to highlight that you can be single and still be happy and secure, as much as you can be if you are married...

    love,
    HK

    ReplyDelete
  3. I guess my views on this are completely different, maybe because of my age. I think it's possible to find someone who exactly suits your needs, or maybe changes your expectations altogether. But unless you keep an open mind, you close up many of the possibilities. You have to try and experiment with different people, it even helps you learn more about yourself.

    As for marriage, I don't believe in doing it only to please others. Actually, I believe the whole system is flawed.

    All the other merits and de-merits of being single end at sex, though, don't you think.

    As long as one doesn't lower their standards as they grow older for fear of eternally remaining single, I guess it's all good.

    (I can;t wait for you to chide me on how childish i still am! )

    ReplyDelete
  4. I have to share that when I was very young (read late teens/early twenties) I was smitten with the concept of soul mates and all that jazz. I loved Richard Bach and his portrayal of a magical relationship in 'Bridge Across Forever' and 'One'. A couple of years later I learnt how that relationship ended and he got divorced (Okay I know, some relationships are not meant to last!!)

    What catches me about your post is, "fear of eternally remaining single". Why FEAR? That was my whole point, its okay, and its great to be single!

    I don't think 'All the other merits and de-merits of being single end at sex', at least not for everyone. The issues surrounding sex loom large for the single as they do for the married. Marriage is more than sex, and singlehood is more than celibacy!

    I think another write up is necessary to address this!

    love
    HK

    ReplyDelete